What Our Customers Say
Welcome to First Choice Auto Repair, your car service in Crest Hill, IL!
If you’re looking for auto repair in Crest Hill, IL, you’ve found us. Here at First Choice Auto Repair we work hard to earn your trust and loyalty. We know how important it is to find a Crest Hill car service you can rely on, so your satisfaction is our top priority each and every day.
Here at First Choice Auto Repair we understand what makes customer service truly outstanding. You will feel the difference exceptional customer care makes when you work with us. We know auto repair in Crest Hill offers you lots of choices, and we aim to provide the kind of caring customer service that will bring you back.
Our Crest Hill car service offers you years of combined expertise from our well-trained technicians. We treat our auto repair professionals well because we value their skill and can-do attitude. We know our team sets us apart, saving you time and money, not to mention worry. When it comes to auto repair in Crest Hill, we are totally confident that First Choice Auto Repair is the best option in town!
Free Shuttle to and from work.
Address
First Choice Auto Repair
2123 Plainfield Rd
Crest Hill, IL 60403
(815) 730-6900
Shop Hours
Mon-Fri: 8am-5pm
Sat-Sun: Closed
*Closed every Friday from 12pm-1pm
Directions
Payment Types




The Absolute Best Car Service in Crest Hill, IL
What sets First Choice Auto Repair apart from all of the others in Crest Hill, IL?
Trust: When it comes to auto repair in Crest Hill, it’s all about earning loyalty and trust by doing our very best every day. We are determined to earn and keep your trust.
Talent: At First Choice Auto Repair, you can rest easy knowing that our highly-skilled, experienced auto service professionals are handling your car. Our technicians bring years of experience, skill, and education to the Crest Hill auto repair table.
Time: We take the time we need to provide you with top quality car service in Crest Hill, and we take the time to talk to you about what that means. We listen to you so we understand your needs and goals for your auto repair.
About First Choice Auto Repair Crest Hill, IL
First Choice Auto Repair is a family-owned and operated repair shop in Crest Hill, IL. We opened in October of 2012 and we really struggled the first few months. Bill decided he had to do something different to help our business take off, so he decided to allow customers to bring their own parts. Melissa thought it was a crazy idea and it would never work, but she was wrong. Bill rolled a sign out to the front of the building that said, “Bring Your Own Parts” and from that day, business picked up. We are the first shop in the area to allow customers to bring their own parts. We do supply parts to those customers that don’t want the task of finding and purchasing their parts. We pride ourselves in providing quality repairs at a fair price.
First Choice Auto Repair stresses the importance of preventative maintenance to our customers. Simple things like oil changes, coolant flushes, and regular inspections will keep your vehicle on the road for a long period of time and avoid costly and untimely breakdowns.
Are you ready to experience the best Crest Hill, IL car service available? Please give us a call or make an appointment here.










Recently Serviced Vehicles
-
2021 Cadillac CT5
Mileage64,629Service Date10/30/2025Services Performed- Tech. inspected and determined all pads have plenty of life left. front rotors developing a rust lip on inner side but are still good.
- Drain and fill engine oil and remove and replace oil filter. Top off all fluids, check battery, lights, belts and hoses.
Kevin M. gave our service a 5 star review on 10/30/2025 -
2013 Ford F-150
Mileage184,388Service Date10/20/2025Services Performed- Drain and fill engine oil and remove & replace oil filter. Top off all fluids, check battery, lights, belts and hoses.
Jonathan G. gave our service a 5 star review on 10/20/2025 -
2016 Jeep Patriot
Mileage73,809Service Date10/20/2025Services Performed- Checked the banging noise and found the sway bar link was loose.
- the car was due for an oil change
- Drain and fill engine oil and remove & replace oil filter. Top off all fluids, check battery, lights, belts and hoses.
- AXLE SHAFT ASSEMBLY – Remove & Install or Remove & Replace – Mfr Body CD MK,FWD Right – [DOES NOT include wheel alignment. DOES NOT include drain and refill Transmission Fluid or Fluid Level check.] – [NOTE: For Independent Suspension Type Axles, Axle Sha
John R. gave our service a 5 star review on 10/21/2025 -
2019 Hyundai Tucson
Mileage77,608Service Date9/22/2025Services Performed- Oil Change
- The code is P0507: Idle Air Control System – RPM Higher than Expected. Further diagnosis is needed.
Carlos M. gave our service a 5 star review on 10/10/2025 -
2009 Chevrolet Impala
Mileage153,154Service Date9/22/2025Services Performed- Car wont go into Park
- Traced down the wire and found the wires to the shift interlock were chafed and broken in multiple spots. repaired the wires and all is working fine at this time.
Rocco C. gave our service a 5 star review on 10/10/2025 -
2009 Nissan Altima
Mileage264,844Service Date10/10/2025Services Performed- ALTERNATOR DRIVE BELT – Remove & Replace – [Includes: Serpentine and V-Belt type Belt(s).]
Bernard T. gave our service a 5 star review on 10/11/2025 -
2013 Ford C-Max
Mileage183,785Service Date10/10/2025Services Performed- Remove and replace customer supplied splash guard
Thomas K. gave our service a 5 star review on 10/11/2025 -
2012 Hyundai Elantra
Mileage212,868Service Date10/3/2025Services Performed- There was a cylinder #1 misfire. The tech checked the spark plugs and they were worn. Tech swapped the cylinder #1 ignition coil with cylinder #2 and the cylinder 1 plug with cylinder #3 plug. The misfire moved to cylinder #1, indicating a bad ignition coil. The air filter was dirty. We recommended a tune-up, including spark plugs, ignition coils and air filter. P0301 P0625
- ELECTRONIC IGNITION (MINOR) – Tune – [Includes: Check compression. Clean or replace Air Cleaner Element and Spark Plugs. Inspect or replace Coil Boots or Ignition Cables.]
Roger G. gave our service a 5 star review on 10/3/2025 -
2012 GMC Acadia
Mileage98,511Service Date9/29/2025Services Performed- Tech. inspected and determined vehicle needs a new AC condenser and a full recharge for repair.
Angel M. gave our service a 5 star review on 10/2/2025 -
2015 Toyota Prius V
Mileage469,794Service Date10/1/2025Services Performed- Tech inspected and tested and determined that the vehicle is in need of replacing the hybrid battery. Recommended to take to the dealer to replace.
Felix O. gave our service a 5 star review on 10/2/2025 -
2010 Dodge Avenger
Mileage140,911Service Date9/30/2025Services Performed- Tech tested and determined that vehicle was in need of replacing the alternator
- ALTERNATOR ASSEMBLY – Remove & Replace – In-Line4 – [Includes: Test.]
Sharon E. gave our service a 5 star review on 10/1/2025 -
2008 Toyota Tacoma
Mileage168,389Service Date9/23/2025Services Performed- Drain and fill engine oil and remove & replace oil filter. Top off all fluids, check battery, lights, belts and hoses.
Mark K. gave our service a 5 star review on 10/1/2025












